There is a debate around the book world that sparks a lot of interest and a whole lot of thoughts on both sides of the spectrum. Are graphic novels, comics, and audiobooks really “reading”? Let’s unpack this!
Now, when someone says “reading,” the classic image of flipping through pages of a traditional book often comes to mind. And of course, that’s a fundamental form of reading. But I think our understanding of what constitutes “reading” needs to evolve with the way we consume stories today.
GRAPHIC NOVELS AND COMICS
Let’s start with graphic novels and comics. They’re a powerful medium that blends visual storytelling with the written word. Think about it: you’re actively decoding a narrative through both text and images. Your brain is working to connect the dialogue bubbles with the characters’ expressions, the panel layouts with the pacing of the story, and the artwork with the overall mood and atmosphere. You’re interpreting visual cues and synthesizing them with the written text to create a complete understanding of the story. To say this isn’t “reading” feels like we’re discounting the way these mediums engage our brains and deliver complex narratives. The visuals aren’t just decoration – they are an integral part of the storytelling language.
AUDIOBOOKS
Now, this is where the “but you’re just listening!” argument often comes in. But let’s really consider what’s happening when you listen to an audiobook. Your brain is actively processing language, building mental images of the characters and settings, and following intricate plotlines. Skilled narrators bring stories to life with their vocal inflections, pacing, and character voices, adding layers of meaning and emotion that can sometimes even enhance the reading experience. For individuals with dyslexia, visual impairments, or those who simply learn better through auditory means, audiobooks provide crucial access to literature. Plus, let’s be honest, being able to “read” while you’re commuting, cleaning, or exercising is a game-changer for fitting more stories into our busy lives!
WHAT IS THE CORE OF READING?
Ultimately, I believe the core of “reading” lies in comprehension and engagement with a story. Whether that is delivered through printed text, a sequence of images and words, or the spoken word, the goal is the same: to understand, connect with, and be moved by a story. To limit the definition of reading solely to the visual decoding of text feels restrictive and ignores the diverse ways we can experience and process information and stories. These different formats offer unique ways to engage with stories and books, and they all require your brain to be actively participating.
So, what are your thoughts? Do you consider graphic novels, comics, and audiobooks to be “reading”? I’d love to hear your perspectives in the comments below! Let’s have a respectful discussion.
